Why You Keep Starting Over (And How to Finally Break the Cycle)

“I keep starting over. Why can’t I just stick with it?”

If that thought hits a little too close to home—you’re not alone. In this episode, we’re unpacking the real reasons people keep falling off track, and what it actually takes to build consistency that sticks.

We cover:
✔️ The dopamine hit of “Day 1” and why the all-or-nothing mindset keeps you stuck
✔️ How emotional eating and escape habits sabotage your best intentions
✔️ Why identity-based goals are more powerful (and sustainable) than outcome chasing
✔️ The truth about discipline that no influencer is telling you
✔️ Why chasing fads leads to burnout—and how the L5 Method helps you build real, lasting results without starting over again

If you’re tired of restarting, this episode will give you the mindset shift and tactical clarity you’ve been missing.

APPLY FOR COACHING:

https://www.lvltncoaching.com/1-1-coaching

SDE Method app:

https://www.lvltncoaching.com/sde-method-app

Macros Guide

https://www.lvltncoaching.com/free-resources/calculate-your-macros

Join the Facebook Community:

https://www.facebook.com/groups/lvltncoaching

FREE TOOLS to start your health and fitness journey:

https://www.lvltncoaching.com/resources/freebies

Alessandra's Instagram:

http://instagram.com/alessandrascutnik

Joelle's Instagram:

https://www.instagram.com/joellesamantha?igsh=ZnVhZjFjczN0OTdn

Josh's Instagram:

http://instagram.com/joshscutnik

Timestamps:

00:00 Introduction to the Fitness League and Episode Overview
05:31 The Evolution of Mindset in Fitness
10:35 Simplifying Habits for Sustainable Change
17:17 Realistic Expectations in Fitness Goals
20:40 The Misconception of Muscle Mass and Fitness Standards
24:50 The Skewed Perception of Fitness
27:59 The Pilates Skinny Talk Era
32:20 The Dangers of Skinny Talk
36:05 Overcomplication in Health and Fitness
41:37 The Role of Identity in Fitness Communities
43:19 The Need for Belonging in Diets
43:51 Identity and Dogmatism in Fitness
45:17 The Impact of Injury on Identity
46:21 Phases of Life and Shifting Identities
47:13 Reestablishing Identity in Fitness
49:44 Understanding Discipline and Motivation
51:18 The Role of Environment in Behavior Change
52:44 Creating Motivation Through Action
54:21 The North Star Concept of Motivation
55:40 Surroundings and Their Influence on Growth

LISTEN NOW

Subscribe to The Fitness League Podcast

Stay up to date on our latest episodes and discussions

Already A Member?

If you're already enrolled in the beta user program, you can log in at the link below. If you are not a current beta member, this link will not give you access. It is for current beta users only.

Join the Waiting List

We're almost ready to go live! Our beta testers are giving final feedback as we wrap up launch development. If you aren't already, join the waiting list to be the first to know when we launch!

Get Exclusive Updates

Subscribe to be notified when new features go live, and how to use them!

By joining, you agree to our Terms and Conditions.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.